AXA results “raise questions” over reality of whiplash fraud ‘crisis’

Evans: impressive revenue growth

Evans: impressive revenue growth

Increasing profits at insurer AXA – one of the leading campaigners for continued whiplash reform – “does not square” with the industry’s warnings of a fraud pandemic, leading claimant firm Thompsons has argued.

AXA’s annual results, published yesterday, showed that underlying earnings in England and Wales were up 25% to £312m – the fifth successive year of double-digit growth – on income of £4.1bn (up 7%).

AXA UK and Ireland chief executive Paul Evans said: “I am delighted that we have been able to deliver impressive revenue growth without compromising profitability.”

UK direct motor revenues increased by 12% to £400m at a combined ratio of 91.4% – meaning that for every £100 in premiums received, AXA spent £91.40 on claims and expenses – which the insurer attributed to both rate increases, and an 8% increase to one million direct motor policies.

Tom Jones, head of policy at Thompsons, said: “Profits are up, and no mention is made of fraud or whiplash – it doesn’t make sense after all the talk of a ‘crisis’ and a ‘pandemic’… We need transparency about claims and fraud so that the consumers can judge for themselves whether or not they are getting a fair deal.”

In a report published in 2013, AXA said that whiplash claimants should have to provide objective evidence of injury – such as an MRI scan or x-ray – and not be allowed to claim where symptoms do not manifest themselves after a few days.

It also called for a code of conduct for insurer/law firm joint venture alternative business structures “to ensure appropriate behaviour” – particularly around referral of “exaggerated ‘whiplash’ claims to their own law firms”.

Mr Evans said that total motor revenues increased 11% to £900m in 2015 due in part to premium increases of over 30% in the Republic of Ireland to reflect the “material increases” seen in court awards for personal injury.

“We call on the Irish government to guide the courts with a schedule of capped, consistent, injury awards which secures affordable insurance for motorists in Ireland,” he said.

Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


30 March 2021

Judicial review reform: A risk to the courts’ post-Brexit standing

In addition to questions about the motivations for curbing legal challenges to political decisions, the proposed reforms to judicial review raise concerns about undermining the reputation of the English courts

Read More