4 April 2013Print This Post

District judge chief: we can handle provisional assessment

Godwin: docketed judge should be more than capable of performing PA

The introduction of docketing should mean that judges are “more than capable” of handling provisional assessment (PA), the new president of the Association of District Judges has said.

Meanwhile, Litigation Futures has divined some explanation for the shock trebling of the PA limit from £25,000 in the pilot phase to £75,000 for the roll-out this week, which specialists warn will catch a lot of bills.

Costs Lawyer, the magazine of the Association of Costs Lawyers, asked District Judge Harold Godwin about district judges’ readiness for PA, especially those who are not regional costs judges.

He said: “One of the objectives of the Jackson reforms is that cases should be case managed and tried, wherever possible, by the same judge (or a team of judges, ie circuit judge and district judge). For cases issued after 1 April, the judge will perform the cost budgeting exercise, which will set the parameters for the final bill in any event. Accordingly, the docketed judges will have a handle on the costs from the outset of the proceedings.

“In gaining that handle, the degree of complexity in any given case will have been apparent. The docketed judge should then be more than capable of performing the PA. If he considers that it should be referred to a costs judge, then he could still do so.

“If the PA is undertaken by the docketed judge, then he will have the benefit of the points of dispute, replies etc, through which both/all parties will have opportunity to explain any complex issues. The explanation will, I anticipate, likely to be fuller than might presently be prepared where an oral hearing is anticipated.

“If the parties’ don’t agree the PA, then they can still call for an oral hearing but on risk of the penalties imposed by the rules as to costs.”

Though there has not been an official explanation for the change in the PA limit, Litigation Futures understands that in the pilot – where the limit was £25,000 in base costs – in practice additional liabilities were also being considered, which meant the total costs being considered were often £60-75,000.

Because costs of this level were being considered at PA without problems, the rule committee decided that the overall limit should be increased to £75,000. The new rule does not mention base costs.

By Neil Rose

Tags: ,


2 Responses to “District judge chief: we can handle provisional assessment”

  1. However any matters in London will not be dealt with by the “same District Judge” and will be sent to the SCCO who will have no prior knowledge of the claim and will have very many bills spread between too few staff

  2. Gary Knight on April 4th, 2013 at 9:47 am
  3. Last I heard, the SCCO can and will be seeking that supporting papers are also sent to assist the PA…..

  4. Melanie Vickery on April 9th, 2013 at 9:19 am