Figures highlight importance of foreign litigants to Commercial Court


Rolls Building: 58 commercial cases in 2013

Four in five of cases in the Commercial Court in the last three years involved a foreign party, figures released in Parliament this week have shown.

They also highlight what a tiny percentage of claims actually result in a trial.

The details published by justice minister Shailesh Vara came in response to a series of questions tabled by shadow justice secretary Sadiq Khan.

In 2012-13, 1,190 claims were issued in the Commercial Court, of which 961 (81%) involved at least one party whose address was outside England and Wales. The figures were similar for the two preceding years.

Mr Vara said there were 58 Commercial Court trials heard in the Rolls Building in 2013, of which five lasted a day, 32 up to five days and a further nine up to 10 days, while 12 cases stretched beyond that.

The figures also showed how the fee income generated by the Commercial and Admiralty Courts has grown in recent years, from £1.1m in 2007-8 to £2.3m five years later.

The government recently consulted on its controversial plan to increase court fees on users of the Commercial Court users, which will raise more than its cost.

Responses from the profession have deprecated the move, with the Commercial Bar Association saying that the Ministry of Justice’s “good work” in promoting the UK as a litigation centre would be undermined by this “dangerous step backwards”.

If fees were regarded as excessive in high-value commercial proceedings, parties would “simply litigate or arbitrate elsewhere”, the association predicted.

There were similar concerns expressed by the City of London Law Society and London Solicitors Litigation Association.

“Court fees might, in themselves, be a relatively small part of the cost to a foreign party of litigating in England, but overtly increasing fees to a level far in excess of the costs involved in order to subsidise unrelated parts of the justice system does not send a message that the courts of England and Wales welcome international business,” said the society’s response.

“The more than sixfold increase in court fees proposed for higher-value cases potentially makes court fees an issue that litigants must consider and will not promote the competitiveness of the English legal services sector.”




Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog

18 October 2018
Claire Stockford

An analogue decision? Google defeats attempt at consumer ‘class action’

In an eagerly awaited judgment, the High Court handed down its ruling in Richard Lloyd v Google LLC on 8 October. It seems clear that there is a degree of reluctance to permit group litigation which will not materially benefit consumers. That being said, it is hard to ignore the increased possibilities of group litigation in the context of corporate data breaches, particularly following the implementation of GDPR earlier this year.

Read More