Law Society refuses to back down in insurer advertisement row

Fluck: important ongoing message to consumers

The Law Society has stepped up the war of words with the Association of British Insurers (ABI) over its personal injury advertising campaign.

ABI director general Otto Thoresen wrote to Law Society president Nick Fluck earlier this week, calling for its £300,000 ‘Don’t get mugged by an insurer – use a solicitor’ campaign to be pulled.

Mr Thoresen labelled the high-profile campaign a “gross error of judgment” and described it as “little more than public name-calling”.

But in response, Mr Fluck yesterday wrote back to Mr Thoresen to express his “puzzlement” at the accusation of name-calling and claimed that the ABI’s press release on the dispute called all lawyers “ambulance chasers”.

Mr Fluck wrote: “We do not consider the campaign to be a gross error of judgment, but rather that it communicates an important ongoing message to consumers. I have no plans to abandon it”.

The central claims in the campaign is that PI claimants should reject an insurer’s initial offer and take legal advice to get an average of three times more compensation.

The ABI said that the data, based on research from the Financial Services Authority (FSA) via the Freedom of Information Act, was “patchy and limited”.

In response, Mr Fluck pointed out that this was because of inconsistent and incomplete responses from ABI members to the FSA, and that the only reason its findings could not be described as conclusive was because of the “unaccommodating” approach of the insurance industry.

In the letter, Mr Fluck invited the ABI to help provide a “solution to this disagreement” by assisting the Law Society and the Financial Conduct Authority in a larger study on the difference in settlement amounts.

He wrote: “The FSA determined there was a real risk in this instance despite the paucity of data provided by the insurance industry.

“I do not accept that the campaign is based on ‘highly misleading and selective use of statistics’. If anything, using the few other statistical findings from the review would only emphasise the point made in the campaign, for example, the finding that only 3-4% of consumers reject the first offer from an insurer, implying ‘possible consumer detriment’.

“It is important to note, as I am sure you will agree, that as insurers hold all the relevant data, the report is the only publicly available data capture that there is.”

The FSA figures are from a study of 113 cases from three insurers, undertaken four years ago.

    Readers Comments

  • Richard W says:

    Very well done Law Society!

    If anything I would write back and say something to the effects of:-

    “We thank you for your comments and are heartened that our campaign is having such a detrimental effect on your members.

    I would like to take this opportunity of just refreshing the memory of your own members and the never ending media coverage slandering our members and the services which they offer. Your campaigns have ultimately resulted in LASPO and a continued reduction of our own members costs whilst at the same time, increasing year by year, your own members profits and the continued funding of this coalition government.

    In view of the response our campaign has generated, we now intend to do a set of television adverts highlighting the dangers of utilising your own member’s services when making a claim. I do hope the campaign will generate a similar response which in turn, help the innocent victim get the totally independent legal advice without conflict from our own members.

    PS The advert’s will be shown during Coronation street in between your own members 6 or 7 adverts!

  • Jack says:

    This Law Society campaign is pathetic.

    The only people who don’t think it’s pathetic are the ambulance chasers…two or three times the damages if you use a solicitor – the public aren’t buying this rubbish anyway…let the Law society kick and scream on the floor like bratty children and get it out of their system.

Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.